Welcome to Southwest Firearms
Join our community, sign up for free today!
Sign Up

Home Defense: Pistols vs. Shotguns vs. Rifles

Messages
3
Reactions
1
In case you're a firearm proprietor, there will come when you'll hear somebody guide you to "simply get yourself a shotgun for home safeguard." The truth of the matter is, however, that guns and rifles can be convenient to have in a home-resistance circumstance, the same amount of as shotgun may be. The trap is realizing what each firearm progresses nicely and what it doesn't progress admirably. For example, guns are useful for moving about and different undertakings where a free hand is required, such as opening entryways, driving individuals to security or potentially holding an electric lamp. Nonetheless, guns are inadequate in capability contrasted with a shotgun or a rifle. A shotgun or a rifle needs two hands to utilize successfully, and they are longer long contrasted with a gun, making them harder to move around inside a house. Shotguns and rifles do have two unmistakable preferences over a gun in a home protection condition, however.

1.Firepower

A 12-check shotgun discharging 00 buckshot tosses 12 .33-gauge lead pellets at one time into its objective. Ouch. A 55-grain .223 projectile weighs essentially not exactly a buckshot load, however that shot is going at a gigantic speed which enables it to bestow a great deal of power to the objective, definitely more than basic handgun gauges. To put it plainly, with regards to capability, guns are guns, and long weapons are long firearms.

2. Separation

An AR-15 rifle in the hands of a semi-equipped marksman is more than fit for conveying shots on-focus out to 100 yards and past, and a shotgun with slugs can hit focuses out past 50 yards. Both of those separations are viewed as outrageous separations for even the most capable of gun shooters.

So which is better for individual safeguard, a handgun, a rifle or a shotgun? As I would like to think, they all have a task to carry out in keeping you and your friends and family sheltered. We should analyze the points of interest and burdens of every one of kind of gun and how that may influence your decision:

Guns

Points of interest: Compact, simple to convey, can be shot with one hand;

Drawbacks: Not much ammunition contrasted with rifles, low-fueled contrasted with long firearms.

Shotguns

Points of interest: Devastating measure of intensity per round, adaptable ammo types;

Inconveniences: Hard to move in difficult situations, needs two hands to work, (generally) low ammo limit.

Rifles

Favorable circumstances: Powerful adjusts. Higher limit. Incredible for long-remove work;

Hindrances: Needs two hands to utilize. Harder to move in difficult situations. A few regions have magazine limit constraints.

I utilize every one of the three, inside and outside the house. Inside our home, we have an assigned safe room, a spot that the whole family knows is our "rally point," the spot we as a whole go to on the off chance that somebody enters our home with malevolence purpose. Inside that sheltered room is a medical aid pack, electric lamp, mobile phone to use for crisis calls, a handgun and an extra magazine. Alongside that is a Mossberg 500 siphon activity shotgun stacked with buckshot, which additionally has about six additional shells and several deer slugs prepared for quick reloads. Our sheltered room is intended to be where the whole family squats and remains until assistance arrives, in light of the fact that beside my family, nothing in my home merits the danger of protecting.

Outside the home, I have a disguised protective handgun on me wherever I can lawfully convey one with me. You've most likely heard that adage that "A .22 on you is superior to a .45 in the truck"? There's a great deal of truth there, so convey your firearms as needs be.

Is a handgun useful for home resistance? Truly, totally. Is a rifle better? Possibly, and perhaps a shotgun is ideal for you. For me, I consider a to be as my essential firearm outside the home and optional inside the home. The siphon activity shotgun is my essential home guarded weapon inside the home.

Your life and your conditions will most likely be not quite the same as mine: Think about where and how you carry on with your life, at that point plan as needs be. On the off chance that you live in a provincial region, the additional separation that a rifle gives you is an interesting point when settling on a decision in a cautious weapon. In the event that you live in an all the more thickly pressed territories, #4 buckshot enters building dividers under #00 shot. Normally, your neighborhood laws will likewise decide how you arm yourself also.

Whatever you picked, focus on preparing with your firearm and instruct the capable gatherings inside your home where your protective weapons are and how they are intended to be utilized. Having an arrangement, notwithstanding having safe stay with a solid locking entryway and a spotlight will put you a long ways in front of the remainder of America. Your arrangement doesn't need to be impeccable, you simply need one.

Best Gun Safe Reviews 2019: Expert Recommendations
 
Messages
57
Reactions
76
Home defense is really self-defense and too often multiple person defense once the home has been penetrated. I spent money on hardening the target and making my home appear less vulnerable than my neighbors' houses. It will take considerable force to gain entry which gives us time to retreat with my cell phone and EDC to our MBR where my Smith and Wesson Governor waits in a RapidSafe.

The Governor loaded with .410 000BK and .45C can be devastating at 7 yards which is the distance between me and the prep(s) once the BR door has been breached. For those not familiar with the Governor, here is a nice article... REVIEW: Why I bought A S&W Governor

A cell phone is on hand to call 911 and order the cavalry to secure the crime scene and search the house and perimeter. I'll stay on the line with the 911 operator so my verbal action and audible sounds are recorded for any possible legal action.

I spent over 33 years on the job and never liked doing house searches for burglars. For me, long guns made it more difficult to search dwellings. I felt safer armed with my S&W 19-4 Combat Magnum.

A good firearm choice depends on many factors and is an even greater asset when combined with solid "what-if" defense plans. We have to look at our own situation and try to identify what maximizes our advantages and minimizes our disadvantages and make an informed decision.

I decided on the S&W Governor because it delivers the firepower of a shotgun and flexibility and retention of a pistol.
 

DB is Here

Messages
681
Reactions
960
Back in 2007 I had an armed burglar come through an open first floor window at 3:00 am one summer night. The alarm went off when he tried to access the door leading into the garage. I grabbed my pistol, walked 15 feet to get my shotgun and thankfully the alarm caused him to leave and not stay and fight.

I've have ample time after that fateful night to reconsider what I'd do differently of which locking my first floor windows and doors is now on my nightly checklist. As for the weapon of choice I'd have to say I'd still grab my shotgun as I wouldn't be clearing the house, just barricading in place and protecting my wife and I if they decided to make entry into my master bedroom.

If I had to clear my house the answer would be different.

The police took 22 minutes to respond...nothing I can do about that.
 

11Charlie

Messages
1,359
Reactions
2,011
I think a lot of what you choose has to be determined on everyone's own personal situation. Living conditions, neighbors, number people in the house and where they are located. All things that can change the way you would do things.

In my situation I would hand my carry pistol to the wife and I would grab my bed side gun and sit tight until the police showed up. Making sure the perp in my house knows that I am armed and that I will use it to end any threat on wife or my life.
 

11Charlie

Messages
1,359
Reactions
2,011
Absolutely. After the police had been called and the alarm turned off I did just that and announced loud enough for all to hear "that we were armed an do not come up the stairs".
And see that all changes if you have family, children or guests staying with you! Where are the rooms located and what do you need to do to protect the loved ones in the house. Are they going to interfere wanting to know what is going on? All these things run through my mind when we have a house full of loved ones.
 

11Charlie

Messages
1,359
Reactions
2,011
We are going to have six people and two grand babies staying with us this weekend. House isn't big enough so two will be sleeping in my man cave on a fold out bed. Not having everyone contained inside the house makes things even worse. I think a convo with the guys will be in order.

If something goes down stay PUT!!! I will clear the house and get to you one room at a time.
 
Messages
779
Reactions
1,216
My biggest fear is crossfire.

My house is split with bedrooms on both sides of kitchen/family room, front and rear doors. Our youngest still lives with us, but keeps a firearm on her nightstand. My wife and I both keep pistols on the nightstands beside our bed. We do not want to meet anybody in the middle. And firing and missing the perp with no knowledge of everyone’s location in the house would be a tragedy in the making.
 

11Charlie

Messages
1,359
Reactions
2,011
My biggest fear is crossfire.

My house is split with bedrooms on both sides of kitchen/family room, front and rear doors. Our youngest still lives with us, but keeps a firearm on her nightstand. My wife and I both keep pistols on the nightstands beside our bed. We do not want to meet anybody in the middle. And firing and missing the perp with no knowledge of everyone’s location in the house would be a tragedy in the making.
Two way radios! Just a thought so the two halves of the house can communicate so everyone knows where you are and this doesn't happen.
 
Messages
57
Reactions
76
I like the walkie-talkie idea of communicating with kids or guests. It is best that people stay secured in their rooms and not getting into harm's way.

We use the Master Lock 265d Door Security Bar on all the exterior doors to include the garage access door and our bedroom doors. Our guest room, often occupied by our son, also has a security bar. These security bars are simple enough for children to manipulate.

My son bought a can air horn which he said he'd use to signal us if he hears someone breaking in at the front of the house while we sleep in the back.
 
Messages
638
Reactions
1,185
I have tons of experience in this very thing and can offer some perspective on things! Pistols are a poor choice, but often the only option we have! Shot guns are great, BUT, ammo selection is absolutely critical if there are others in the home or neighbors close by! A Rifle can be the best option, but ammo is also extremely important! The right ammo will make all the difference in the world, for good or Ill!

Personally, I choose the Pistol and Rifle! Again, Years of experience! For Pistol ammo, a Ultra fast moving, deep penetrating hollowpoint is the preferred ammo. In Rifle, a Light weight, high energy hollowpoint is the choice! I want maximum bleeding of the tango, and minimized over penetration and I want my shots to expend energy rapidly so that I don't pass through walls, or at least minimize the chances a round will leave the room! That is the most critical factor, passing through walls! The very worst is Shotguns running buck shot and or slugs! If I were to use a shotgun, it would be loaded with #2 lead bird shot! Slugs and Buck are well known to pass through walls, and considering that, you are responsible for every one of those pellets that passes through your walls!

Years ago, there was a home invasion and the Father used a 12 gau loaded with 00Buck to defend his family and home, unfortunately, one of his shots passed through the wall behind the tangos and killed his 4 year old sleeping in her bed!
Another one, same situation, but defender was using slugs! Opened fire on the tango and one slug passed through the outer wall of his home, and passed through his neighbors outer wall and struck him in his bed and killed him!

If your going to use a shotgun, I really don't want to be your neighbor!

Same thing with Rifle and pistol ammo! Old family friend was out hunting and thought he had cleared his rifle, brought it home and put it in the closet, the rifle went off and the bullet went through the ceiling and killed his little daughter who was playing with her barbies in her room!

Ultimately, your choice of ammo is more important then WHAT you choose to arm your self with! Until very recently, the infamous 9 mm (9X19) was known far and wide for over penetration and was capable of lethal results after passing through all sorts of obstructions, and thus a very poor choice for HD use! This is part of the Arguments of 9 mm Vs .40 Vs .45 and the much heated discussions that followed! Simply put, the "Old" .45 was big and slow moving, and wouldn't penetrate walls with lethal results on the other side!

Todays Rifle Ammo choices offer much in the HD environment, with the 5.56 leading the way, it's well proven at stopping threats at close range and stopping in walls or if it does penetrate, it isn't as likely to kill on the other side! In my experience, THIS is the best tool for the job! A nice light and handy, plane Jane AR Carbine is my go to for HD use!
 
Messages
98
Reactions
91
I have an old CHP riot gun 12 gauge loaded with #8 birdshot 2 3/4" shells. I have given much thought as to having my rounds clearing my neighborhood. The second and backup is my father's Remington 1911 with the welded sights, left over from the Korean War. I never use sights when shooting it. It is all instinctive shooting. It has 165 gr jacketed hollow points which mushroom easily. Hopefully my dog will alert me to the problem before I am jolted from my sleep.
 
Messages
73
Reactions
177
What works for me and my situation...is just that , what works for me...it could be vastly different for someone else and their situation.
My choice for defense of hearth and home is my 1981 Remington Wingmaster in 12 gauge with a 18 inch Improved Cylinder choked barrel...loaded with #4 buck , since it shoots this load well.

I grew up shooting a 1962 Wingmaster , it is the first gun that I have owned and I have owned and shot it for a long time now...
Using the newer Wingmaster for both close range grouse and as home defense gun was a easy transition.
Andy
DSC06837.jpg
 

LATEST REVIEWS

  • Arizona Firearms - Tempe
    5.00 star(s)
    I went there today to pick up a firearm and had a very good experience. I will shop there again.
    • MadDuner
  • Arizona Firearms - Tempe
    5.00 star(s)
    Every time I go in there I leave with what I needed and without feeling like my wallet was raped.
    • Mrjenkins
  • Arizona Firearms - Tempe
    5.00 star(s)
    Anyone in Phoenix area should check out Arizona Firearms on University and Priest. They have a big selection of firearms and have great prices.
    • JonathanB
  • Murphy's Guns and Gunsmithing
    5.00 star(s)
    When I go in I usually will watch and listen to employees before I choose which one to talk to. The good employees are great to talk with. The...
    • Gunsandgars
  • Murphy's Guns and Gunsmithing
    4.00 star(s)
    I have purchased new and used from them. I was lucky a while back and they had a Armalite AR10A with a lot of accessories that I just had to have...
    • Belevolk